Table 4

Association between patient/clinical characteristics and consumption of a delayed antibiotic in 150 patients who consulted with 66 cliniciansa with LRTI and were issued with a delayed prescription

VariableOdds ratio95% CIP-value
Patient characteristics
Age (decades)1.150.86 to 1.540.343
Sex: Female (Ref)
Male
0.550.22 to 1.380.204
No comorbidities (Ref)
At least one comorbidity0.550.17 to 1.820.326
Employed (Ref)
Not employed1.000.39 to 2.541.000
Patient illness information
 Clinician rated symptom severity at consultationb1.130.78 to 1.640.545
 Patient rated symptom severity on day 1b0.990.72 to 1.350.938
 Waited <7 days before consulting (Ref)
 Waited ≥7 days before consulting0.860.35 to 2.130.746
Clinician working diagnosis
 Lower respiratory tract infection (Ref)
 Asthma/COPD-related illness0.350.05 to 2.600.308
 Upper respiratory tract infection0.350.12 to 1.000.050
 Non-specific respiratory tract infection0.210.05 to 0.970.046
 Viral/other illness0.110.02 to 0.530.005
Duration of advised delay
 <7 days (Ref)
 ≥7 days0.380.11 to 1.290.120
Patient behaviour
 Patient did not want antibiotics (Ref)
 Patient wanted antibiotics2.511.06 to 5.900.035
Clinician perception ‘This patient wanted me to prescribe antibiotics for them’
 Clinician does not agree (Ref)
 Clinician agrees0.380.15 to 1.000.050
Clinician perception: ‘Antibiotics will help this patient get better quicker’
 Clinician does not agree (Ref)
 Clinician agrees1.300.52 to 3.220.573
  • COPD = chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

  • a The clinician-level intracluster correlation coefficient (using the standard π2/3 estimator) was 0.10.

  • b OR for a 10 percentage point increase