This month's BJGP reports an observational study of screening for testicular descent which makes the claim that such screening is worthwhile in older boys.1 The authors advocate the reinstatement of the previous screening regimen for testicular descent at 9 months and 3.5 years.2 Is this a sensible recommendation?
The current UK National Screening Committee evidence-based programme recommends screening for undescended testes (UDT) at birth and at 8 weeks but not for older boys. A previously published audit of delayed orchidopexy concluded that ascent of a previously scrotal testis was the likely cause for late diagnosis of UDT rather than a failure of screening.3 This would explain the consistently high mean age at which boys undergo orchidopexy reported from all over the world, despite the introduction of ‘aggressive’ UDT screening.4
It is increasingly recognised that ascending testes are more common than previously thought and are more likely to have a history of being retractile.5 Although most retractile testes do not require surgery,6 they should not be considered a normal variant, as some can ascend in older boys necessitating orchidopexy.7 The regular follow-up of boys with retractile testes is recommended rather than the introduction of a more general screening programme for older boys.5
SCREENING AND EXAMINATION
Screening for early childhood illness is important and can be done well in general practice. For most children, the early detection of congenital conditions, such as hip dysplasia, cataract, coarctation of the aorta, and UDT, can make a real difference to their future health. The key issues for us as GPs are the timing of the screening, our competency to undertake the necessary examinations, and the practice resources required to deliver the programme.
As the optimal management of retractile and ascending testes remains controversial, we believe that our current focus should be on ensuring our competency to carry out the 6- to 8-week examination, actively following up all infants who default on their screening appointments, and opportunistically screening any boy at a later date if there is parental concern.2
QUALITY STANDARDS
The delivery of high-quality child health care remains a core component of general practice. All GPs should be competent and be able to demonstrate that they are proficient in recognising and managing acute and chronic illness in children, and in organising their practices to administer timely health promotion and preventative care to all children and their parents. Developing and maintaining competence in the care of children and young people requires high standards of clinical training, regular clinical exposure, continuing education, and audit of performance.
The care of children and young people needs to be adequately reflected within accreditation, governance, the Quality and Outcomes Framework, and research in general practice.8 We believe the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) should lead on making child health a priority area for primary care by assuming responsibility for developing a wider range of quality standards in general practice for children and young people.
Setting quality standards for the care of children and young people is not new for the RCGP. Extensive work has already been undertaken by the RCGP Adolescent Health Primary Care Society and the Royal College of Nursing through its Getting it Right for Teenagers in Your Practice campaign.9 In addition, an RCGP toolkit for Safeguarding Children and Young People in general practice10 has been developed in collaboration with the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children.
New RCGP quality standards for all children and young people should be based on the best available evidence and set alongside national priorities, such as the National Service Framework for Children, Young People and Maternity Services.11
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR IMPROVEMENTS
It is our view that the RCGP should also support an increase in the leadership capacity for child health for general practice. Every practice, federation, or commissioning group should have a GP with a special interest in child health who can lead on safeguarding, clinical standards, and organisation as well as the configuration of practice-based services for children and young people. In addition, the RCGP should consider the introduction of a diploma or higher accreditation in child health specifically aimed at the cohort of GPs in their first 5 years in practice. This would give an opportunity for those doctors to develop a special interest in child health, increase future leadership capacity, and send a strong signal to other potential providers of primary health care to children that the RCGP is determined to build on and improve the delivery of GP-led care to children and young people.
Notes
Provenance
Commissioned, not externally peer reviewed.
- © British Journal of General Practice, January 2011