Skip to main content

Main menu

  • HOME
  • ONLINE FIRST
  • CURRENT ISSUE
  • ALL ISSUES
  • AUTHORS & REVIEWERS
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • BJGP LIFE
  • MORE
    • About BJGP
    • Conference
    • Advertising
    • eLetters
    • Alerts
    • Video
    • Audio
    • Librarian information
    • Resilience
    • COVID-19 Clinical Solutions
  • RCGP
    • BJGP for RCGP members
    • BJGP Open
    • RCGP eLearning
    • InnovAIT Journal
    • Jobs and careers

User menu

  • Subscriptions
  • Alerts
  • Log in

Search

  • Advanced search
British Journal of General Practice
Intended for Healthcare Professionals
  • RCGP
    • BJGP for RCGP members
    • BJGP Open
    • RCGP eLearning
    • InnovAIT Journal
    • Jobs and careers
  • Subscriptions
  • Alerts
  • Log in
  • Follow bjgp on Twitter
  • Visit bjgp on Facebook
  • Blog
  • Listen to BJGP podcast
  • Subscribe BJGP on YouTube
Intended for Healthcare Professionals
British Journal of General Practice

Advanced Search

  • HOME
  • ONLINE FIRST
  • CURRENT ISSUE
  • ALL ISSUES
  • AUTHORS & REVIEWERS
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • BJGP LIFE
  • MORE
    • About BJGP
    • Conference
    • Advertising
    • eLetters
    • Alerts
    • Video
    • Audio
    • Librarian information
    • Resilience
    • COVID-19 Clinical Solutions
Out of Hours

Remodelling Medicine

Martin Marshall
British Journal of General Practice 2013; 63 (613): 432. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3399/bjgp13X670813
Martin Marshall
Professor of Healthcare Improvement, UCL, London.
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • For correspondence: martin.marshall@islondon.org
  • Article
  • Figures & Data
  • Info
  • eLetters
  • PDF
Loading
JEREMY SWAYNE Saltire Books, 2012 HB, 507pp, £39.99, 978-1908127006
Figure

Do you ever feel vaguely uncomfortable about the dominance of biomedicine in our health system? Do you have a creeping anxiety about the ways in which we are incentivised to focus on diseases rather than people and are you concerned that biomedicine is creating public expectations and economic demands that are undeliverable? I suspect that many of us have these concerns, although we rarely surface them and even less frequently feel able to do anything about them. Biomedicine is powerful and persuasive, so much so that not only doctors but also many patients, policy makers, and system leaders act as if it is the only model on which to base health care.

If you share these nagging concerns then Remodelling Medicine is for you. And if you don’t then perhaps it is even more important that you read the book. The author, Jeremy Swayne, trained as a basic scientist and has worked as a GP, a teacher, a homoeopathist, and a church minister — a good pedigree to challenge medicine from both within and without. In an informative, passionate, and provocative way, Swayne takes us on his personal and professional journey, his battles with values, ideas, and paradigms. It is an aspirational book and a brave one.

Swayne describes how the preoccupation with the scientific method which underpins the practice of biomedicine has led to what he calls ‘a state of paradigm paralysis’. He talks much about the hubris of biomedically-oriented doctors and the need to exhibit greater humility if we are to be more effective in helping our patients. He suggests that we will only rediscover the healing vocation of medicine, we will only be successful in integrating science with caring, if we re-engage with other ways of thinking and knowing. He draws heavily on his expertise in the field of complementary and alternative medicine to illustrate what these other ways of acquiring knowledge could look like.

The book has a meandering style. The prose is sometimes repetitive, and frequent cross-referencing within the text can be distracting. But in many ways these criticisms reflect the joy of the book; the narrative mirrors Swayne’s journey and a rigorous edit may remove the soul of the story.

The author seems to me to adopt a rather narrow and stereotypical view of what science is about. He seems to conflate the design and intent of the scientific method, as a rigorous and systematic way of generating knowledge, with its application in practice. The latter, like all practice, is often imperfect and occasionally flawed. He confuses scepticism, one of the basic tenets of the scientific method, with dogmatism. Well-trained scientists reject ideology, work with ambiguity, and are sensitive to the strengths and flaws of the epistemologies underpinning their methods. Their challenges are not that different from those of grounded clinical practitioners.

But the more significant problem for me with Remodelling Medicine is that it isn’t clear who the book is meant to influence. If it is a manifesto, and it reads like one, then presumably the author has political intent. Is he trying to bolster the views of those who are already persuaded by the arguments, persuade those who are receptive to thinking differently, or convert the sceptics?

The latter is where a difference could really be made but the use of phrases like ‘psychic energy’ and ‘doctrine abuse’ are unlikely to engage those who hold power in the current system, the people who need to be persuaded if we are to challenge the dominance of biomedicine. The book is highly stimulating but I am not confident that it will change the world.

  • © British Journal of General Practice 2013
Back to top
Previous ArticleNext Article

In this issue

British Journal of General Practice: 63 (613)
British Journal of General Practice
Vol. 63, Issue 613
August 2013
  • Table of Contents
  • Index by author
Download PDF
Download PowerPoint
Email Article

Thank you for recommending British Journal of General Practice.

NOTE: We only request your email address so that the person to whom you are recommending the page knows that you wanted them to see it, and that it is not junk mail. We do not capture any email address.

Enter multiple addresses on separate lines or separate them with commas.
Remodelling Medicine
(Your Name) has forwarded a page to you from British Journal of General Practice
(Your Name) thought you would like to see this page from British Journal of General Practice.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Citation Tools
Remodelling Medicine
Martin Marshall
British Journal of General Practice 2013; 63 (613): 432. DOI: 10.3399/bjgp13X670813

Citation Manager Formats

  • BibTeX
  • Bookends
  • EasyBib
  • EndNote (tagged)
  • EndNote 8 (xml)
  • Medlars
  • Mendeley
  • Papers
  • RefWorks Tagged
  • Ref Manager
  • RIS
  • Zotero

Share
Remodelling Medicine
Martin Marshall
British Journal of General Practice 2013; 63 (613): 432. DOI: 10.3399/bjgp13X670813
del.icio.us logo Digg logo Reddit logo Twitter logo CiteULike logo Facebook logo Google logo Mendeley logo
  • Tweet Widget
  • Facebook Like
  • Google Plus One
  • Mendeley logo Mendeley

Jump to section

  • Top
  • Article
  • Figures & Data
  • Info
  • eLetters
  • PDF

More in this TOC Section

Out of Hours

  • Viewpoint: Redundant subjectivity?
  • Books: A Layman’s Guide to Psychiatry and Psychoanalysis
  • Can compassion help cure health-related disorders?
Show more Out of Hours

Books

  • The Winter War
  • All Human Life and Loss in Palestine
  • Little Pieces of the Wreckage
Show more Books

Related Articles

Cited By...

Intended for Healthcare Professionals

BJGP Life

BJGP Open

 

@BJGPjournal's Likes on Twitter

 
 

British Journal of General Practice

NAVIGATE

  • Home
  • Current Issue
  • All Issues
  • Online First
  • Authors & reviewers

RCGP

  • BJGP for RCGP members
  • BJGP Open
  • RCGP eLearning
  • InnovAiT Journal
  • Jobs and careers

MY ACCOUNT

  • RCGP members' login
  • Subscriber login
  • Activate subscription
  • Terms and conditions

NEWS AND UPDATES

  • About BJGP
  • Alerts
  • RSS feeds
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

AUTHORS & REVIEWERS

  • Submit an article
  • Writing for BJGP: research
  • Writing for BJGP: other sections
  • BJGP editorial process & policies
  • BJGP ethical guidelines
  • Peer review for BJGP

CUSTOMER SERVICES

  • Advertising
  • Contact subscription agent
  • Copyright
  • Librarian information

CONTRIBUTE

  • BJGP Life
  • eLetters
  • Feedback

CONTACT US

BJGP Journal Office
RCGP
30 Euston Square
London NW1 2FB
Tel: +44 (0)20 3188 7400
Email: journal@rcgp.org.uk

British Journal of General Practice is an editorially-independent publication of the Royal College of General Practitioners
© 2023 British Journal of General Practice

Print ISSN: 0960-1643
Online ISSN: 1478-5242