Jump to comment:
- Page navigation anchor for Learning from experienceLearning from experience
It is welcome to see this advice on withdrawing from SSRI drugs published.1 I congratulate the authors and the BJGP. Four years ago, the Royal College of Psychiatrists published a position statement on antidepressants and depression,2 so I had expected similar advice to be published in the equivalent journal for psychiatry. This has not yet happened.
The BJGP article states that “Inaccurate guidance on antidepressant withdrawal has resulted in many patients experiencing distressing, debilitating symptoms” and in ‘Take-home messages’ [Box1] that “GPs should educate patients on withdrawal”. Box 1 returned my mind back to when I was training in psychiatry. At this time, a 5 year long “Campaign” was underway to “Defeat Depression”. I recall the “key messages”, for example in this paper ‘General Practice: Lay people’s attitudes to treatment of depression: results of opinion poll for Defeat Depression Campaign just before its launch’3 which stated unequivocally “Patients should be informed clearly when antidepressants are first prescribed that discontinuing treatment in due course will not be a problem”.
In 2023, across the UK, 1 in 6 adults are now taking an antidepressant. Such mass prescribing is well beyond the 1 in 20 prevalence on which the Defeat Depression Campaign was based.
Vanessa Cameron, the Chief Executive Of...
Show MoreCompeting Interests: None declared. - Page navigation anchor for A step change in guidance on withdrawing antidepressantsA step change in guidance on withdrawing antidepressants
Palmer et al’s article aiming to translate the recent change in NICE guidance to GPs is timely and useful.1 Dr Butler’s negative response to the article is understandable given how big a shift the updated NICE guidance on stopping antidepressants represents from previous guidance.
While his personal experience is valuable double-blind randomised controlled trials demonstrate that 53.9% of patients who stop antidepressants will experience withdrawal effects.2 The minimisation of these effects in guidelines for decades has meant that withdrawal effects are commonly mis-diagnosed as relapse.3 This is why there are currently tens of thousands of English patients seeking advice on how to stop antidepressants on peer support sites,4 rather than their doctors - hardly consistent with withdrawal effects being exaggerated by NICE.
Although it was considered thrifty to avoid prescription of liquid versions of medications, a shift in policy has been signalled by NICE which specifically recommends to GPs “if…slow tapering cannot be achieved using tablets or capsules, consider using liquid preparations if available.”5 8 out of 10 of the most commonly used antidepressants are available as liquids; sertraline is available in liquid form as a “Special.”
Dr Butler rightly points out a difficulty with concentrated solutions of citalopram. However, he is mistaken in think...
Show MoreCompeting Interests: I have been commissioned by Health Education England (HEE) to prepare a module on how to safely stop antidepressants using hyperbolic tapering for NHS staff on the SCRIPT website. I have been commissioned to write the Maudsley Deprescribing Guidelines, a textbook on deprescribing antidepressants and other psychiatric drugs, by Wiley Blackwell. I am a Collaborating Investigator on the RELEASE trial in Australia investigating supported, gradual, hyperbolic tapering of antidepressants. I am a member of the Critical Psychiatry Network and an Associate of the International Institute for Psychiatric Drug Withdrawal (IIPDW). I am a co-founder of Outro Health which helps people who wish to stop unnecessary antidepressant medication in Canada and the US using gradual, hyperbolic tapering. - Page navigation anchor for Withdrawing from SSRI antidepressants - practical help is neededWithdrawing from SSRI antidepressants - practical help is needed
As a person who has endured a lengthy and complicated withdrawal process from an antidepressant, I am delighted to see this issue gaining recognition. I thank the authors for their work.
We are starting to move from a position where antidepressant withdrawal is seen as rare and self-limiting, to one where we can acknowledge that, for a proportion of people, the withdrawal process can be extremely difficult. Furthermore, some people will continue to have problems long past the point that they got off the antidepressant. Some psychopharmacologists believe this is due to the adaptation that the brain has made to the drug. Examples of this are often seen in online fora where some people report difficulties for months or years after tapering.
While I welcome this work, more needs to be done to practically aid both prescribers and patients in safely stopping antidepressants. As noted in other letters, liquid forms are available for some drugs but not all, and they tend to be expensive.
The Netherlands has led the way in developing tapering strips which can provide a precise and reliable way to gradually taper. In the UK, we should be learning from such ground-breaking work, and I got the chance to speak with Professor Wendy Burn, the then President of the Royal College of Psychiatrists about this issue.
Some readers might be interested to know about tapering strips and how they can aid the prescriber in guiding patients safely and slowly off their...
Show MoreCompeting Interests: None declared. - Page navigation anchor for Withdrawing from SSRI antidepressants: advice for primary careWithdrawing from SSRI antidepressants: advice for primary care
With regards to Palmer et al’s article in RCGP Journal March 2023 I would like to make the following points.
My lived-in experience has shown many patients simple stop SSRIs outside medical recommendation with minimal reported side effects so perhaps we are exaggerating withdrawal issues.
Liquid medications are few and far between. For example, sertraline and paroxetine do not have liquid versions. The flow chart with regards to citalopram is impractical. The only liquid form is 40mg/1ml making the suggested doses of 0.6-5mg, impossible to deliver. Any dilution is out of licence.
As per the comments in the article, fluoxetine has a half life of several days in chronic use (and its active metabolite norfluoxetine longer1 so withdrawal from this drug can easily be achieved by simple tailoring regimes. Thus, one method not mentioned is to switch patients onto fluoxetine and withdraw from this SSRI instead.
If we recall, Prozac was the first SSRI of use and all others that followed were “me-to” products of Big Pharma, merely developed to get a slice of the significant financial action. Logically they have no tangible benefit over fluoxetine, all working on the same 5 HT pathway. So, therefore, fluoxetine should be considered the drug of choice?
Reference
1. Fluoxetine - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf (nih.gov).
Competing Interests: None declared. - Page navigation anchor for Managing withdrawal symptoms using tapering stripsManaging withdrawal symptoms using tapering strips
In their acclaimed article, Palmer and colleagues question how GPs should deal with those who experience withdrawal symptoms. In the Netherlands tapering medication has been developed to help GPs and other practitioners to do precisely that.1 Tapering strips and stabilization strips enable them to flexibly prescribe and adjust personalized gradual and hyperbolic tapering schedules, based on shared decision making and proper self-monitoring. This tapering medication has been prescribed to more than 10.000 patients, allowing us to investigate whether and to what extent they have benefited from it. Because 60% of them had tried unsuccessfully tried to stop using an antidepressant in the past when they experienced severe withdrawal symptoms, it was possible to make within-subject comparisons between stop attempt(s) without and with the use of tapering strips.2-4 These comparisons showed that about 70% of patients who were not able to stop in the past when they suffered from severe withdrawal were able to stop using tapering strips, the use of which resulted in much less withdrawal. Tapering strips and stabilization strips can also be prescribed to and used by patients in the UK.5
References
1. Groot & van Os. How user knowledge of psychotropic drug withdrawal resulted in the development of person-specific tapering medication. Ther Adv Psychopharmacol 2020; 10....
Show MoreCompeting Interests: Tapering medication is a non-patented product containing generic drugs and can be made by any compounding pharmacy. P.C. Groot was involved in the development of tapering strips and both authors research tapering strips. Neither author is involved in any way in the production or sale of tapering strips. In the Netherlands, tapering medications are made, at the specific request of the not-for-profit foundation Cinderella Therapeutics, by the Regenboog pharmacy in Bavel, The Netherlands, against a nationally pre-set, regulated reimbursement. Other pharmacies in the Netherlands do not produce tapering strips as the pre-set reimbursement is considered too low. The User Research Centre at UMC Utrecht has benefitted from an educational grant provided by the Regenboog Pharmacy. - Page navigation anchor for Withdrawing from SSRI antidepressants: advice for primary careWithdrawing from SSRI antidepressants: advice for primary care
The authors have provided valuable information regarding the clinical features of SSRI/antidepressant withdrawal syndromes. The reference to hyperbolic tapering in withdrawal regimes is of particular relevance to maximising the chances of success. The concern regarding increased risk of suicidal ideation is addressed; however, the life threatening problem of withdrawal induced akathisia may be an area worthy of discussion and increased awareness. Akathisia is vulnerable to misdiagnosis, not only of the original condition. The writhing restlessness, disorientation, intensity of suffering, and inability to describe what is happening may lead to misdiagnosis as serious mental illness (eg 'psychotic depression" and 'bipolar disorder') leading to psychotropic poly-pharmacy and increased intensity of akathisia.
Healy and colleagues1 have identified the importance of awareness of post SSRI sexual dysfunction (PSSD):
"The data make it clear that SSRIs and SNRIs are potent disrupters of sexual function and that adverse sexual effects can sometimes persist for years or indefinitely after discontinuation of the drug. In some cases these effects only emerge, or worsen, when the drug is withdrawn. It also appears that post- treatment problems can occur after only a brief exposure to the drug".
"Post SSRI sexual dysfunction, and its mirror image, persistent genital arousal disorder can be life-changing, making it difficu...
Show MoreCompeting Interests: None declared. - Page navigation anchor for Withdrawing from SSRI antidepressants: advice for primary careWithdrawing from SSRI antidepressants: advice for primary care
I am so glad that this article has been published. For some years, I was saddled with a poor prognosis, told that I had a recurrent depressive disorder and advised to take antidepressants for life. As I became more confident after the crisis had passed, returned to work and was completely well, the side effect burden became too much. I did not know anything about tapering or that 'withdrawal' was a recognised entity, nor did my GP. However, I was very aware of the effects of missing a dose, which lead to what are known as 'brain zaps' and so I cut down on venlafaxine and trazodone slowly. It was fairly easy at first, but as I got to lower doses, I was surprised at how difficult it became. Unknowingly I 'tapered' because I had to cut up tablets into tiny, tiny pieces and take just enough to deal with the symptoms. It took me two years in all to withdraw from venlafaxine. Trazadone was harder. After the last dose, I had severe rebound insomnia and after 3 nights with no sleep at all and a restlessness, which I assumed was RLS, I couldn't bear it any longer and put myself back on a small dose. When I finally took the last dose, I immediately developed what is now diagnosed as a 'small fibre neuropathy' and there are others who have similar symptoms - thought to be a protracted withdrawal syndrome. It has lasted years. However, my mental health hasn't been better. If I had known any of this, before I agreed to take antidepressants for wh...
Show MoreCompeting Interests: None declared.