THE TRAFFIC LIGHT SYSTEM
This review analyses current evidence for the diagnostic accuracy of the Traffic Light System (TLS) in primary care, its implications for GPs, and its alternatives. Two linked studies1,2 of the performance of the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence’s TLS concluded that it was unfit for purpose. TLS aims ‘to improve clinical assessment and help healthcare professionals diagnose serious illness among young children [under 5] who present with fever’,3 a notoriously difficult assessment since fever in children is common while serious bacterial infection (SBI) is rare. The TLS groups clinical features into three categories with corresponding recommendations: red (serious illness likely, hospital admission recommended), green (serious illness unlikely, manage at home), and amber (intermediate risk, judgement required). Clark et al2 reported that the TLS was insufficiently accurate to identify infants in primary care with SBI and to exclude those without. Arguably these findings suggest abandoning the TLS. In preparing this review, all references from both studies were retrieved. Backward and forward searches from the references were cascaded until no new references were found.
WHAT CLARK AND BLYTH FOUND
Blyth et al1 and Clark et al2 mapped data from the previous prospective cohort DUTY study4 of over 6700 children presenting with constitutional or urinary tract infection symptoms to GPs, walk-in centres, and emergency departments (EDs) to TLS items. A third of under-5s had at least one red feature.1 The accuracy of the TLS, using hospital-diagnosed SBI as the reference standard, was calculated for two thresholds: any red feature and either red or amber feature.2 Any red feature had a sensitivity of …
RCGP login
Members, please Login at RCGP to access the journal online
Subscriber login
Enter your BJGP login information below.
Log in using your username and password
Log in through your institution
Pay Per Article - You may access this article (from the computer you are currently using) for 1 day for US$35.00
Regain Access - You can regain access to a recent Pay per Article purchase if your access period has not yet expired.