Abstract
Background Adverse pregnancy outcomes (APOs) affect approximately 30% of pregnancies and confer lifelong elevated cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk. Behavioural interventions may mitigate this risk.
Aim To systematically review qualitative literature on women’s experiences of behavioural change for cardiovascular risk reduction following APOs, with a focus on health equity.
Design and setting Qualitative systematic review, limited to high-income countries with universal access to health care.
Method A systematic search of PubMed, Embase, and CINAHL from inception to March 2025 identified primary studies. Thematic synthesis followed Thomas and Harden’s three-stage approach. Themes were mapped onto the COM-B (Capability, Opportunity, Motivation-Behaviour) framework to theoretically ground and structure analysis.
Results Eighteen studies involving 339 women met inclusion criteria. Women who were minority ethnic formed the majority in only two studies. Demographic data regarding socioeconomic status, ethnicity, or both were absent from five. Experiences shaping behaviour change aligned with COM-B domains. Delayed physical and psychological recovery after APOs reduced women’s capability to initiate changes. Competing demands, including childcare, household responsibilities, and work, restricted opportunity to focus on long-term cardiovascular health. Opportunities improved when behaviour changes were easily integrated into family life and offered shared benefits. Motivation was strengthened by awareness of increased CVD risk, the responsibilities of parenthood, and personalised advice from healthcare professionals. Tailored, proactive follow-up supported engagement, especially for minority ethnic and socioeconomically disadvantaged groups.
Conclusion Prevention of CVD after APOs requires structured, system-level support to prioritise family-based behaviour change. High-risk groups are underrepresented in research; coproducing interventions with these groups may help to avoid widening health inequalities.
How this fits in
It is well established that adverse pregnancy outcomes (APOs) are associated with increased long-term cardiovascular disorder (CVD) risk. Annual glycosylated haemoglobin (HbA1c) checks for women after gestational diabetes are recommended, but other interventions for postpartum CVD risk identification and reduction are not part of routine general practice in the UK. Increased patient and practitioner awareness of APOs as a CVD risk factor, monitoring of modifiable risk factors, and development of behaviour change interventions for women following APOs may reduce CVD morbidity and mortality in this patient group.
Introduction
Nearly one in three pregnancies is affected by one or more adverse pregnancy outcome (APO). APOs include hypertensive disorders of pregnancy (HDP), gestational diabetes (GDM), preterm labour, and intrauterine growth restriction.1 These pregnancy-specific conditions serve as early warning signals for a woman’s lifelong health trajectory. Women who experience APOs have an approximately two-fold increased risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) including ischaemic and valvular heart disease, heart failure, and stroke.2–4 CVD risk can be reduced by addressing behavioural risk factors. Behaviour changes such as improving cardiovascular fitness, eating a heart-healthy diet, and avoiding smoking have the potential to reduce premature morbidity and mortality.5 Regular monitoring of CVD risk factors including blood pressure and metabolic blood markers allows early identification of women who would benefit from pharmacological intervention for additional risk reduction.6
A 2021 national cohort study indicated that socioeconomic and ethnic inequalities were responsible for a substantial proportion of APOs; the largest inequalities are seen in Black and South Asian women in the most socioeconomically deprived quintile. The authors commented that ‘prevention should target the entire population as well as specific minority ethnic groups at high risk of adverse pregnancy outcomes, to address risk factors and wider determinants of health’.7 These women are underrepresented in cardiovascular research.8,9
The UK government’s 2025 10 Year Health Plan for England aspires to tackle health inequalities and improve overall health outcomes through shifts from treatment to prevention, hospital to community, and analogue to digital.10 Successful primary care interventions to reduce the cardiovascular risk of women following APOs could bring about shifts towards community and preventive care. The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidance on hypertension in pregnancy recommends that women who have had HDP should be informed of its association with an increased risk of hypertension and cardiovascular disease in later life.11 This recommendation is echoed in the 2025 Mothers and Babies: Reducing Risk through audits and confidential enquiries (MBRRACE) report.12
This study aims to synthesise the existing qualitative literature exploring women’s experiences of behaviour change to address CVD risk following APOs with a particular focus on high-risk groups.
The research questions asked were:
what are the barriers and facilitators to engagement in postpartum behaviour change for CVD risk reduction following APOs; and
to what extent have women from minority ethnic and socioeconomically deprived groups been represented in these studies and how do their experiences differ from other patient groups?
Method
This review was reported in accordance with the Enhancing Transparency in Reporting the Synthesis of Qualitative Research (ENTREQ) guidelines. The protocol was registered with the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO), registration number CRD420250654735.
Eligibility criteria
For eligibility criteria see Box 1.
Box 1. Search strategy inclusion and exclusion criteria A comprehensive search was conducted using three electronic databases; PubMed, Embase, and CINAHL. The search period was from inception of the databases until 17 March 2025; searches were repeated on 15 December 2025.
A combination of search terms for ‘Adverse pregnancy outcomes’, ‘postpartum’, ‘cardiovascular’, and ‘intervention’ were used (see Box 2). Forwards and backwards citation searching were performed to identify additional studies that were missed by our searches.
Owing to the nature of qualitative data and lack of translation services, searches were restricted to studies available in English. A methodological specialist provided advice on development of the search strategies.
Study selection
Search results were imported first into RefWorks software for deduplication and then into Rayyan software for screening. Two independent reviewers (the first and the second authors) screened the titles and abstracts and then read the full texts of candidate papers, documenting reasons for exclusion. All conflicts were resolved with discussion. A third reviewer was available to resolve persistent conflicts.
Data extraction
Two authors (the first and the fifth authors) independently extracted a comprehensive dataset for five of the 18 studies (28%). Discrepancies were resolved by discussion. A high level of agreement was observed so the first author completed data extraction for all remaining papers.
Quality evaluation
Two independent researchers (the first and the fifth authors) assessed the methodological rigour of each study using the 10-item Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) checklist13 (Supplementary Table S1). Contextual thickness and conceptual richness were also assessed for each study14 (Supplementary Table S2). Disagreements were resolved by discussion. Studies were not excluded based on quality evaluation, but methodological weaknesses were considered when determining the relative contributions of studies to the overall review findings.
Data synthesis
Two independent authors (the first and the second authors) coded the results sections of all studies. This involved line-by-line coding using both Nvivo Version 14 software and handwritten methods. Codes were methodically and inductively grouped to provide descriptive themes closely matching data from the original studies. This process was completed for all papers collectively and then subsequently for the diverse and non-diverse papers separately. This step was done by hand, using colour coding to allow differences between the two subgroups to be visualised. Descriptive themes were further synthesised to generate analytical themes focused on our research questions. Code and theme development underwent multiple reviews and iterations.
Initially synthesis was conducted following the three stages of ‘thematic synthesis’ outlined by Thomas and Harden.15 During theme development, the team identified that the descriptive and contextualised themes could be mapped to the COM-B (Capability, Opportunity, Motivation-Behaviour) model and the final analysis was therefore completed using COM-B as a framework.16 The COM-B model was developed to allow researchers to achieve a theoretical understanding of behaviour to determine what needs to change for the behavioural target to be achieved. It also illuminates what intervention features may be effective to bring about the desired change.
Certainty of evidence
Certainty of the review findings were assessed using Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation Confidence in Evidence from Reviews of Qualitative research (GRADE-CERQual) (Supplementary Table S3).17
Reflexivity
The research team comprises six women, three from ethnic minority backgrounds, with professional roles ranging from medical student to professor. All share a commitment to women’s health and health equity. Our lived experiences as women, some from minoritised communities, potentially sensitise us to postnatal care inequities, while our professional backgrounds may introduce assumptions around medicalised frameworks of risk. We have sought to remain reflexive throughout the review process.
Results
Electronic searches performed in March 2025 retrieved 2986 records. After removing duplicates, 1887 titles and abstracts were considered for inclusion. In total, 1763 were excluded at the title and abstract stage, leaving 124 for full-text evaluation. Sixteen studies were included from the original searches. Reasons for exclusion are detailed in the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses) diagram (Figure 1).18 Two additional studies were identified by reference and citation searching, bringing the total number for inclusion to 18.19–36
Seventeen qualitative studies and one mixed-methods study were included. Six were conducted in the Netherlands, five in Australia, four in Canada, and three in Norway. Three studies interviewed women referred to specialist secondary-care postpartum clinics addressing CVD risk after APOs. Four involved women enrolled in telephone or online-based behavioural interventions. Two evaluated question prompt lists designed to support communication about CVD risk after APOs during routine postnatal appointments. Nine studies explored women’s broader views on making behavioural changes to reduce cardiovascular risk following APOs.
Across all studies, the perspectives of 339 women were represented. Three studies did not provide data on the ethnicity of participants and four studies did not provide a measure of socioeconomic status. Of the participants whose ethnicity was reported 76% (n = 228) were White. Two studies drew on the same patient group and were counted only once in this total. One study included women with and without APOs; only those with APOs were included.
Characteristics of included studies are provided in Supplementary Table S4.
Methodological quality
All studies achieved at least 7 of the 10 points available in the CASP model (Supplementary Table S1); a lack of reflexivity among researchers was the most missed criteria. Reporting of this review was guided by the standards of the PRISMA statement.37
Themes and sub-themes are summarised in Supplementary Table S5.
Theme one: capability
The sub-themes in theme one were:
postnatal recovery;
knowledge of CVD risk;
timing; and
self-advocacy.
Sub-theme one: postnatal recovery
APOs can take a physical and psychological toll on women. Some women become acutely unwell owing to their APOs, many require emergency deliveries, and their babies may suffer serious health complications . Extended hospital admissions for mother and/or baby are common. Many described ongoing psychological distress and a consequent inability to receive information about their own long-term health in the subsequent weeks:
‘At 6 weeks I was just a crying mess and had only just come out of the special care nursery with my baby … I think it would have definitely bombarded me at that time.’ (Jenkinson et al, woman who had experienced HDP [Australian, non-diverse])27
Sub-theme two: knowledge of CVD risk
Capability to address CVD risk required knowledge of that increased risk. Most women said that acquiring this knowledge motivated them to make behavioural changes:
‘We have heart problems in our family on my father’s side, so it’s not unrealistic that something could happen to me too […] So it was a bit of an eye-opener when we started to get signs that things weren’t quite right. It makes you pull yourself together, you realise you can’t just wait till your children have moved out.’ (Gustavsen et al, woman with experience of GDM [Norwegian, socioeconomically diverse])
24
This was not always the case. Some women did not consider the information relevant to them:
‘I don’t consider myself having high blood pressure. I was more than happy to partake in the research, but I don’t feel like I have high blood pressure, so it hasn’t really made a difference … I don’t know if I actually read any of it [study brochures] just because, I know it sounds silly, but I don’t know if I identify as being really unhealthy.’ (Rossiter et al, woman with experience of HDP [Australian, non-diverse])31
Sub-theme three: timing
Women were clear that information about risk and advice about behaviour change should be provided at a time suitable to the individual, once they had recovered sufficiently to be able to process the information and consider acting on it. Views on the appropriate timing varied greatly depending on the severity of APO and recovery times. Those who recovered quickly suggested the 6-week postnatal check as the ideal time to talk about long-term CVD risk, because it was convenient and the experience of APOs was still fresh in their minds:
‘Right after the birth is a bit early, but the 6-week check-up would have been a good time for me. It’s okay to address it while you’re still a bit affected by it, you shouldn’t wait too long. I think the information should be given early, especially if you want to change your diet and start being more active.’ (Arntzen et al, woman with experience of pre-eclampsia [Norwegian, socioeconomically diverse, ethnically non-diverse])20
Other women needed much longer to recover sufficiently to be able to absorb and process the information:
“‘After 6 months you might start to recognize yourself and get some energy again and then you also get room for questions and for new information I think.’” (Dijkhuis et al, woman with experience of pre-eclampsia [Dutch, no diversity data])22
Sub-theme four: self-advocacy
There were very few examples of women having been aware of their long-term increased CVD risks before involvement in the research studies:
‘And I had no idea, three kids later, preeclampsia three times, about what the future risks are for me in relation to heart health.’ (Dubrofsky et al, woman with experience of pre-eclampsia [Canadian, non-diverse])23
Once informed, some women self-advocated for follow-up care to address their CVD risk. We observed a clear divide between papers with a non-diverse (highly affluent/educated) participant group and papers where there were more diverse participants; only the most educated and health literate sought follow-up autonomously:
‘It is then up to the patient to continue that post care with their GP ... when I go to the GP now and even if it’s for, I had a fingernail infection. I’m like, “While I am here, he can take my blood pressure” ... I am so mindful to keep an eye on it now.’ (Roth et al, woman with experience of HDP [Australian, non-diverse; 100% of participants in this study had tertiary-level education])32
Studies with more diverse recruitment found that women only engaged with follow-up if it was scheduled for them:
‘No, I didn’t have a follow-up check. That’s actually also because she said you have to schedule [the appointment] yourself, but I didn’t really feel like it. So, in the end it didn’t happen.’ (Reilingh et al, woman with experience of GDM [Dutch, socioeconomically and ethnically diverse])30
Women said that proactive follow-up helped them to prioritise their care:
‘The follow-up should have been like the cervical screening program, where you get a reminder. There should [sic] a proper system.’ (Arntzen et al, woman with experience of pre-eclampsia [Norwegian, socioeconomically diverse, ethnically non-diverse])20
Theme two: opportunity
The sub-themes in theme two were:
competing priorities;
support networks; and
achievable changes.
Sub-theme one: competing priorities
Participants described busy lives with multiple competing responsibilities restricting opportunities to prioritise their own health:
‘The baby’s probably number one, work’s probably two, and then the exercise will come after that. I am doing it, but it’s not as much as I had previously done.’ (Rossiter et al, woman with experience of HDP [Australian, non-diverse])31
Women described feeling guilty for taking time away from their other responsibilities to exercise but were more comfortable accessing activities that their children could also benefit from:
‘More programmes where you can bring your children would be really great. Because that’s what I’m struggling with, I can’t quite manage to prioritise myself. But if it’s something I can see my little boy will also enjoy, it’s that much easier to get involved.’ (Gustavsen et al, woman with experience of GDM [Norwegian, socioeconomically diverse])24
Sub-theme two: support networks
Women reported feeling isolated following APO. They valued opportunities to meet women with similar experiences:
‘I look healthy so the general practitioner also doesn’t do much about it. […] It was difficult to find people who went through the same … even the specialist had trouble helping me. Thank goodness for social media.’ (Van Oortmersson et al, woman with experience of pre-eclampsia [Dutch, non-diverse])34
Peers provided emotional support, encouragement, and accountability to maintain behaviour changes:
‘When you’ve got people and you form friendships they’re going to help you stay accountable for your health, for follow up appointments, they’re going to say, hey are you coming to this appointment? Come, you’ve got to look after yourself for bub (baby). So you’ve got someone encouraging, you’ve got your group encouragement whereas some of these girls (young mothers) might not otherwise have that support network.’ (Andraweera et al, woman with experience of APO [Australian, socioeconomically diverse])19
Partners and the wider family were variable in their impact. When other household members also adopted changes, women were more able to maintain healthy behaviours:
‘After all, my partner and I eat the same food and go for walks together. It would be easier if we were both making healthy choices.’ (Arntzen et al, woman with experience of pre-eclampsia [Norwegian, socioeconomically diverse, ethnically non-diverse])20
Conversely, family members could undermine women’s attempts to make changes:
‘Their intentions to eat healthy food were jeopardized by their partner eating unhealthy snacks. One woman with GDM said: “My partner’s got a very sweet tooth. We’ve tried to discuss eating candy only at weekends and keeping off soft drinks and energy drinks. But when he’s in the store, he’s just got to have some snacks. I’m trying to keep off it but it’s not so easy then.”’ (Sandsæter et al, woman with experience of GDM [Norwegian, non-diverse])33
Within studies including ethnically diverse participants, there were examples of women benefitting from mutual support from relatives who also had cardiometabolic problems, whereas others felt stigmatised or blamed for their health problems and attempts to alter behaviours were seen as inconvenient. These phenomena were not reported in the non-diverse studies:
‘Women with ethnic minority backgrounds more often spontaneously mentioned the relevance of having family members with diabetes or CVD who actively supported them with advice (eg, to reduce salt intake, home blood pressure monitoring and routine monitoring). At the same time, family members had a negative influence when the family members felt it was a burden to adjust dietary patterns to their needs, dismissed their health concerns or implied they were to blame for the pregnancy complications.’ (Reilingh et al [Dutch, socioeconomically and ethnically diverse])30
Sub-theme three: achievable changes
Behavioural modification could be facilitated by encouraging small, achievable adjustments that fit into family routines. Some women had previous experiences of abandoning attempts to improve their cardiovascular health when they had tried to make ambitious, unsustainable changes:
‘What I liked was the less strict approach. You don’t have to change your whole life and go on a diet and all that, but there are lots of small steps that help with the big picture […] We’ve made a lot of small changes that aren’t really that difficult, but they’re still important.’ (Gustavsen et al, woman with experience of GDM [Norwegian, socioeconomically diverse])24
Theme three: motivation
The sub-themes in theme three were:
Sub-theme one: parenthood
The ability to play a full and active part in family life motivated women to make behaviour changes:
‘The participants considered it important to be good health role models, to positively influence their children’s future health and to participate in their children’s activities when they were older.’ (Sandsæter et al, participants had either pre-eclampsia or GDM [Norwegian, non-diverse])33
Parenthood also made women more fearful of adverse health events, motivating them to engage with care:
‘You need to see people every 12 months, so if people are slipping in their eating habits or starting to get high blood pressure, you might be able to get them more education to stop it. If you don’t see them, they might get worse, and nobody wants to have a heart attack when you have kids.’ (Manthorpe et al, woman with experience of APO [Australian, socioeconomically and ethnically diverse])
28
Sub-theme two: personalised follow-up and accountability
Women had received generic advice about healthy behaviours in the past that had been insufficient to prompt change. Advice that was individually tailored was both more relevant and motivating:
‘One of the women reflected on why she managed to change her lifestyle this time after several previous unsuccessful attempts. “Talking to someone who looks at my situation. Not general advice for everyone but looking at my problem […] Yes, that motivates me a lot more”.’ (Gustavsen et al, woman with experience of GDM (Norwegian, socioeconomically diverse])
24
Participants of studies involving longitudinal follow-up clinics valued the time and attention that was offered:
‘The clinic is not like other clinic appointments with doctors where it’s like “here is what you have to do, off you go” and there is no follow up and nobody cares how you are going. You truly care.’ (Manthorpe et al, woman with experience of APO [Australian, socioeconomically and ethnically diverse])
28
Continuity and a sense of accountability were both motivational; knowing that they would be reviewed helped women to maintain behaviour changes:
‘It’s really strange. This ... faceless person, but you actually do feel like ... it does make you want to achieve what you’ve said you’re going to do, because you’ve openly said it to someone.’ (Rossiter et al, woman with experience of HDP [Australian, non-diverse])
31
Discussion
Summary
This thematic synthesis of qualitative studies, thematically grounded within the COM-B framework, provides an insight into the factors that influence women’s attempts to change behaviour to reduce CVD risk after APOs. A focus on research inclusivity and health equity was chosen because of disproportionate risk of APOs in certain minority ethnic groups and women who are socioeconomically deprived. Some differences were observed between papers that recruited diversely and those that did not.
Although the COM-B model provided a useful structure for our analysis, we observed overlap and interplay between domains. For example, although knowledge of CVD risk was presented within the theme of capability, it could also be considered as a motivating factor; knowledge of CVD risk gave women the psychological capability to recognise the importance of behaviour change, while acquisition of this knowledge provided motivation to make changes. In the domain of opportunity ‘competing priorities’ acted as a barrier to women accessing health care and adopting healthy behaviours, while in the capability domain, women described how being invited to appointments helped them to prioritise their own care alongside these competing priorities.
Strengths and limitations
Scientific rigour was established through systematic search methods, critical appraisal of included studies, and application of the GRADE-CERQual approach. All stages of the searching, appraisal, and analysis were conducted independently by at least two authors. The large, diverse sample of patient perspectives strengthens transferability. No UK-based studies were identified; however, by limiting searches to high-income countries with universal access to health care we expect findings to be transferable to UK patients. Mapping descriptive themes to the COM-B model facilitated identification of intervention features that could be targeted to promote behaviour change.
Separate analysis of studies employing diverse versus non-diverse recruitment strategies was conducted, aiming to identify differences between the experiences of these groups. Several publications lacked details on ethnicity or socioeconomic status, with five studies reporting neither. Where data was available, studies were classified as having diverse recruitment using predefined criteria of <70% White participants and <70% representation from the upper socioeconomic bracket (economic, employment, or education status as reported in the individual studies). The data were not sufficiently rich to allow exploration of the difference in experiences between, for example, women of different ethnicities. It is recognised that considering all minority ethnic women and women who are socioeconomically deprived as a single ‘diverse’ group is an oversimplification.
Review findings were shared with a patient and public involvement group of Black African ethnicity with experience of APOs. They verified that the findings reflected their own experiences but added that the long hours of darkness and inclement weather of the British winter were a barrier to physical activity, a finding not captured in this review.
Comparison with existing literature
This review identified that low self-prioritisation was an important barrier to women addressing CVD risk after APOs. In their 2024 systematic review, Dwyer et al found that lack of self-prioritisation was a barrier to women caring for their own health that spanned continents and disease types.38 For example, if dietary changes were disliked by family members, women reverted to old dietary habits to the detriment of their own health. This reluctance to self-prioritise appears to be deeply rooted in traditional gender roles.38 Our review suggests that a whole-family approach to behaviour change rather than targeting women’s individual behaviours may be helpful. In their 2023 systematic review of GPs’ views and experiences of providing postnatal care, Macdonald et al found that GPs believed they had a key role in caring for women postnatally, but were challenged by time constraints, lack of clear clinical guidance, and suitable communication from secondary care.39 GPs felt able to provide better care when they had ready access to a multidisciplinary team, particularly valuing access to health visitors.39
Implications for research and practice
Since April 2026, annual glycosylated haemoglobin (HbA1c) or fasting blood sugar for women with previous GDM has been included in the Quality and Outcomes Framework in England.40 This was an important step towards recognising the importance of APOs for women’s long-term health, but this review suggests that to meaningfully address CVD risk following APOs a comprehensive programme of postnatal care is needed.
There was a notable absence of UK studies in this review. Qualitative work with women in the UK with purposive sampling of high-risk groups would enrich understanding of the challenges and potential solutions for these women. This would help to inform coproduction of an intervention dedicated to CVD risk reduction after APOs. Ultimately, it is envisaged that this intervention would be one element of a framework, guiding the care of women from the point of APO diagnosis throughout the whole life-course.
Although further research is needed, this review provides indications of how primary care practitioners can support CVD risk reduction after APOs. First, accurate coding of APOs in hospital maternity discharge summaries and subsequently the primary care electronic health record would allow alert-and-recall systems to support proactive care. Second, inviting women to a booked postnatal appointment rather than using an opt-in model would encourage more women, especially those from the highest-risk groups, to attend. This recommendation is backed by NHS England’s 2026 toolkit to improve postnatal care, which requests that integrated care boards ensure all eligible women receive a formal invitation for a 6–8-week GP postnatal review.41 Third, in accordance with NICE guidance,11 cardiovascular risk information should be provided at the postnatal appointment. This review indicates that this information may need to be repeated at a future appointment for those whose recovery is prolonged. A review 3 months after delivery should be considered in these cases. A 3-month review aligns with other existing guidance including NICE’s recommendation to assess renal function at 3 months for women with postnatal proteinuria after pre-eclampsia, and the advice to repeat HbA1c 13 weeks after birth for women following GDM. Finally, women with previous APOs should be encouraged and supported to access family-centred behavioural change where available. Allied health professionals such as health visitors, community support workers, health trainers, or social prescribers could be candidates to deliver these services.
In conclusion, this study highlights that women who have experienced APOs are motivated to make behaviour changes to reduce their long-term CVD risk, but face barriers to do so. Primary care can support this group through proactive follow-up with structured, community-based support.
Notes
Funding
Victoria Hodges is funded by an NIHR In-practice Fellowship (NIHR305174). The views expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care.
Provenance
Freely submitted; externally peer reviewed.
Acknowledgements
We thank Dr Nadia Corp and Jodie Heap for help with development of the search strategies and Furaha Women’s Hub for their valuable input.
Competing interests
The authors have declared no competing interests.
- Received February 17, 2026.
- Revision received March 31, 2026.
- Accepted May 18, 2026.