Skip to main content
Main menu
HOME
ONLINE FIRST
CURRENT ISSUE
ALL ISSUES
AUTHORS & REVIEWERS
SUBSCRIBE
CONFERENCE
MORE
About BJGP
Advertising
eLetters
Alerts
BJGP LIFE
Video
Audio
Librarian information
Resilience
COVID-19 Clinical Solutions
RCGP
BJGP for RCGP members
BJGP Open
RCGP eLearning
InnovAIT Journal
Jobs and careers
User menu
Subscriptions
Alerts
Log in
Search
Search for this keyword
Advanced search
Intended for Healthcare Professionals
RCGP
BJGP for RCGP members
BJGP Open
RCGP eLearning
InnovAIT Journal
Jobs and careers
Subscriptions
Alerts
Log in
Follow BJGP on LinkedIn
Follow bjgp on BlueSky
Visit bjgp on Facebook
Blog
Listen to BJGP podcast
Subscribe BJGP on YouTube
Visit bjgp on Instagram
Intended for Healthcare Professionals
Search for this keyword
Advanced Search
HOME
ONLINE FIRST
CURRENT ISSUE
ALL ISSUES
AUTHORS & REVIEWERS
SUBSCRIBE
CONFERENCE
MORE
About BJGP
Advertising
eLetters
Alerts
BJGP LIFE
Video
Audio
Librarian information
Resilience
COVID-19 Clinical Solutions
One in a million? At least two!
Sandra
van Dulmen
,
Professor in Communication in Healthcare
,
Nivel (Netherlands institute for health services research), Utrecht, the Netherlands
Other Contributors:
Janneke
Noordman
,
Senior researcher, Nivel (Netherlands institute for health services research)
,
Nivel (Netherlands institute for health services research)
Liesbeth
van Vliet
,
Researcher, Nivel (Netherlands institute for health services research)
,
Nivel (Netherlands institute for health services research)
Richard
van Kruysdijk
,
Video manager, Nivel (Netherlands institute for health services research)
,
Nivel (Netherlands institute for health services research)
7 May 2018
In their ‘One in a million’ paper Jepson et al describe their initiative to create a ‘unique’ archive of videotaped consultations. They thereby justly refer to Byrne and Long’s study from 1976 as the ground breakers in collecting video-recordings of real-life patient encounters. However, they do not seem to be aware that since 1975, a steadily growing archive of, at present, 18,000 video-recorded consultations linked with medical and patient information is being built at Nivel (Netherlands institute for health services research). This archive has so far resulted in hundreds of papers, also published in this journal.
1
In 2006, Jozien Bensing received the prestigious Dutch scientific Spinoza award for her work in this area and in 2016 the archive was selected by The Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences as a promising research facility. Our archive originally included only GP visits, but since 1995 also captures visits with practice nurses, medical specialists (e.g. gynecologists and, clinical geneticists), home care nurses, pharmacists, midwives, etc. We have also collected video-recordings outside the Netherlands (Germany, Switzerland, Belgium, Spain, Sweden, Estonia, Romania, Poland and … the UK).
2,3
Our database allows us to make historical comparisons of interactions,
4
to study the impact of policy measures (patient participation, shared decision-making), to look at the role of diversity, to examine triadic and group interactions and the effects of interventions for patients or healthcare professionals.
5
We have the infrastructure with up-to-date hard- and software and a video manager on a fixed position to guarantee high quality and reliable observations. This allows us to do video-observations in a safe environment taking into account privacy measures as laid down in our protocols and in conformity with Dutch privacy regulations.
6
Video-feedback is given to the participating healthcare professionals for which they earn CME credits. Under strict conditions, the archive is available for secondary analyses. So, while we applaud Jepson et al for setting up this very useful database, instead of a ‘one in a million’ it is at least a ‘two in a million’ initiative. We are open to collaboration.
References
1. Karasz A, Dowrick C, Byng R,
et al
. What we talk about when we talk about depression: The role of conceptual models in shaping doctor patient consultations.
Br J Gen Pract
2012;
62:
e55-e63.
2. Brink-Muinen A van den, Verhaak PFM, Bensing JM.
The Eurocommunication Study
. Utrecht: NIVEL; 1999.
3. Peltenburg M, Fischer JE, Bahrs O,
et al
. The Unexpected in Primary Care. A Multicenter Study on the Emergence of Unvoiced Patient Agenda. Ann Fam Med 2004; 2: 534-540.
4. Noordman J, Verhaak P, I. van Beljouw I van, Dulmen S van. Discussing patient’s (un)healthy lifestyle in the consulting room: analysis of GP-patient consultations between 1975 and 2008.
BMC Fam Pract
2010;
11(1):
87.
5. Weert J van, Jansen J, Spreeuwenberg P, Dulmen S van, Bensing J. Effects of a communication skills training to improve communication with older cancer patients: A randomized controlled trial.
Critical Reviews in Oncology/Hematology
2011;
80:
145-159.
6. Dulmen S van, Humphris G, Eide H. Towards a guideline for person-centered research in clinical communication; lessons learned from three countries.
IJPCM
2012;
2:
58-63.
Competing Interests:
None declared.