Table 4

Mean improvement for both recruitment groups and both intervention groups on primary outcome measures after 12, 26 and 52 weeks.a

Differences between groups
GP Mean (sd)Advertisement Mean (sd)Mean95% CIP-valuebEffect size
Main improvement on primary outcome measures for graded exercise therapy
Main complaints (0–100)n = 41n = 46
 12 weeks35.8 (28.3)30.0 (23.0)5.8−5.1 to 16.80.2940.23
 26 weeks43.6 (27.9)33.7 (25.0)9.9−1.4 to 21.10.0850.37
 52 weeks49.1 (28.1)33.9 (23.3)15.34.3 to 26.20.0070.60
SDQ (0–100)
 12 weeks22.2 (26.1)12.4 (25.3)9.9−1.1 to 20.80.0770.39
 26 weeks27.2 (28.1)18.5 (29.5)8.7−3.6 to 21.00.1620.30
 52 weeks27.1 (26.2)18.3 (25.9)8.8−2.3 to 19.90.1200.34
Mean improvement on primary outcome measures for usual care
Main complaints (0-100)n = 42n = 47
 12 weeks28.9 (22.7)22.1 (25.9)6.8−3.5 to 17.10.1920.28
 26 weeks34.7 (28.0)28.2 (28.0)6.5−5.3 to 18.40.2740.23
 52 weeks37.8 (28.1)26.5 (25.9)11.4−0.3 to 22.70.0510.42
SDQ (0–100)
 12 weeks19.6 (22.0)11.6 (20.7)8.0−1.0 to 17.00.0800.37
 26 weeks28.3 (29.8)13.1 (24.0)15.23.9 to 26.60.0090.57
 52 weeks28.7 (32.5)13.0 (28.2)15.72.9 to 28.50.0170.52
  • a After unconditional mean imputation.

  • b Statistically significant P<0.01. sd = standard deviation. SDQ = Shoulder Disability Questionnaire.