Reproducibility (% adequate)
Author, publication yearCountrySettingStudy populationNumber of patientsFEV1, %FVC, %
Primary care practice
 Schermer et al,I 2009 (current paper)The NetherlandsRoutine careAdults and children ≥12 years from 15 primary care practices10914340
 Tuomisto et al, 200827FinlandRoutine carePatients from primary care health centres48978 to 80a,b
 Walters et al, 200828AustraliaResearchAdults from eight primary care practices61844 to 76a,c
 Eaton et al,II 19999New-ZealandResearchAdults and children from 30 primary care practices10123 to 14a,c
 Schermer et al,I 200322The NetherlandsResearchPatients with COPD recruited from 61 primary care practices39982d
 Zanconato et al,III 200529ItalyResearchChildren from 10 primary care paediatric practices10994a
Pulmonary function laboratory
 Enright et al,IV 200430USRoutine careAdult patients from one outpatient pulmonary function laboratory18 000>95>90
 Enright et al,V 200015USRoutine carePublic schools students aged 9–18 years from middle-income communities40009397
 Bellia et al,VI 200019ItalyResearchPatients ≥65 years attending one of the 24 involved pulmonary or geriatric institutions1622>94>87
 Stoller et al,II 199731USResearchPatients with severe α1 antitrypsin deficiency, from 37 hospitals1090>95>91
 Enright et al,VII 199116USResearchCigarette smokers 35 to 60 years of age included in a clinical trial5887>99
  • Studies conducted in pulmonary function laboratories are included as points of reference. Studies have used different definitions for reproducibility, which limits direct comparison of results.32

    Definitions used in the respective studies are:

  • I Two highest FEV1 values <5% and <200 ml;

  • II Largest FEV1 values and largest FVC values ≤200 ml;

  • III Two highest FEV1 values and FVC values ≤5%;

  • IV Difference between highest and second-highest FEV1 <150 mL;

  • V FVC and FEV1 values at least 95% of the largest values;

  • VI Difference between highest and second-highest value <200ml for FEV1 and FVC;

  • VII Difference between highest and second-highest FVC <200ml.

  • a Reproducibility results not reported for FEV1 and FVC separately.

  • b For pre- and postbronchodilator tests respectively.

  • c For usual and trained practices respectively.

  • d Reproducibility calculated without prior selection of acceptable blows according to 1994 American Thoracic Society spirometry guidelines.6

    COPD = chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.