Quote | Justified reasons | Referenced | Method stated | |
---|---|---|---|---|
UK guidelines | ||||
BHS recommendations on BP measurement 1986 | BP should be measured in both arms in all patients with high BP at the initial assessment, and if a reproducible difference of 20 mmHg for systolic pressure and 10mmHg for diastolic pressure simultaneous measurements should be performed | Partial | No | No |
BHS-1 1989 | – | – | – | – |
BHS-2 1993, BHS-3 1999 | Not mentioned in text directly but refers to BHS recommendations on BP measurement 1986 | – | – | – |
BHS-4 2004 | BP should initially be measured in both arms as patients may have large differences between arms | Partial | No | No |
NICE 2006 | Measure blood pressure on both of the patient's arms | No | No | No |
MHRA 2006 | BP should initially be measured in both arms … A difference in BP between the arms can be expected in about 20% of patients | Yes | No | No |
CKS library, 2007 | Initially, measure the BP in both arms, as there can be large differences between arms (greater than 10 mmHg) | Partial | No | No |
US and Canadian guidelines | ||||
JNC-1 1977, JNC-2 1980 | – | – | – | – |
JNC-3 1984, JNC-4 1988, JNC-5 1993, JNC-6 1997, JNC-7 2003 | The physical examination should include: an appropriate measurement of BP, with verification in the contralateral arm | No | No | No |
AHA 1980 | On the initial examination, one should record the pressure in both arms | No | No | No |
Canadian hypertension education program 2007 and 2008 | BP should be taken in both arms on at least one visit. | No | No | No |
New Zealand, Australian and Japanese guidelines | ||||
Heart Foundation of Australia 2008 | At the patient's first BP assessment, measure the BP on both arms, thereafter, use the arm with the higher reading | No | No | No |
Heart Foundation of Australia 2004 | Measure BP on both arms at the first visit, particularly if there is evidence of peripheral vascular disease. A variation of up to 5 mmHg in BP between arms can be acceptable | No | No | No |
New Zealand Cardiovascular Guidelines 2005 | Not mentioned | – | – | – |
JSH 2003 | The BP difference between the arms must be evaluated. If a difference of BP between the arms is apparent, the BP should usually be measured with the arm that shows the higher BP | No | No | No |
South African Guidelines | ||||
Hypertension Guideline 2003, 2000 | All measurements should preferably be taken using the same arm | No | No | No |
Hypertension guideline 1995 | Not mentioned | – | – | – |
International guidelines | ||||
WHO/ISH 1989 WHO/ISH 1999 | Measure the blood pressure in both arms on the first visit if there is evidence of peripheral vascular disease | No | No | No |
ESH-ESC practice guidelines 2007, ESH-ESC 2003 | Measure BP in both arms at first visit to detect possible differences due to peripheral vascular disease | Yes | No | No |
ESH 2003 | … a recent study has shown significant differences in inter-arm differences for systolic and diastolic blood pressure, leading to the recommendation that bilateral measurement should be made on first consultation … | Yes | No | No |
EJCPR 2003 | At the initial visit, BP values from both arms should be obtained to detect patients in whom atherosclerotic plaques in subclavian or more central arteries may be responsible for substantial between-arm discrepancies | Yes | No | No |
Note: Justification has been italicised. AHA = American Heart Association; BHS = British Hypertension Society; BP = blood pressure; CKS = Clinical Knowledge Summaries; EJCPR = European Journal of Cardiovascular Prevention and Rehabilitation; ESC = European Society of Cardiology; ESH = European Society of Hypertension; JNC = Joint National Committee; MHRA = Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency; JSH = Japanese Society of Hypertension; NICE: National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence; WHO/ISH = World Health Organisation/International Society of Hypertension.