Table 1

Specialty of operator, anatomical site of biopsy, and biopsy method by setting, n (%).

Primary careSecondary careP-value
Specialty<0.001
n2621001
GP157 (59.9)6 (0.6)
GP frequent excisera93 (35.5)22 (2.2)
Plastic surgeon10 (3.8)512 (51.1)
Dermatologist0 (–)152 (15.2)
General surgeon2 (0.8)218 (21.8)
Other hospital specialists0 (–)91 (9.1)
Anatomical site<0.001
n248960
Head and neck32 (12.9)260 (27.1)
Body72 (29.0)225 (23.4)
Upper limb61 (24.6)133 (13.9)
Groins0 (–)23 (2.4)
Lower limbs83 (33.5)319 (33.2)
Site unknown1441
Biopsy method0.02
n2621001
Excisional245 (93.5)895 (89.4)
Incisional2 (0.8)41 (4.1)
Punch biopsy7 (2.7)45 (4.5)
Total otherb8 (3.1)20 (2.0)
Information from abstracts
n169468
Abstract diagnosis<0.001
Correct33 (19.5)256 (54.7)
Incorrect30 (17.8)54 (11.5)
Not stated106 (62.7)157 (33.5)
Abstract qualityc0.032
Comprehensive29 (17.2)50 (10.7)
Adequate130 (76.9)401 (85.7)
Inadequate10 (5.9)17 (3.6)
Biopsy site0.215
Stated160 (94.7)453 (96.8)
Not stated9 (5.3)15 (3.2)
  • a GPs who had excised ≥5 melanomas in study period.

  • b Comprises curettage, shave, operative, enucleation, and amputation.

  • c Data available only from 29 March 2000 to 5 July 2007.