Table 2.

Risk of bias assessment

CategoryCriteriaStudy
Brooks et al (1972)7Christiaens et al (2002)8Ferry et al (2004;9 200710)
Defined sampleDescription of source of patients, and inclusion and exclusion criteriaYesYesYes
Representative sampleParticipants selected as consecutive casesYesNot reportedNot reported
Follow-up rateOutcome data available for at least 80% of participants at one follow-up pointYesYes57% at 5–7 weeks, but>80% at 8–10 days
PrognosisRaw data, percentages, survival rates, or continuous outcomes reportedYesYesYes