Shuttle versus six-minute walk test in the prediction of outcome in chronic heart failure☆
Introduction
Although measurement of peak oxygen uptake provides a valuable assessment of functional capacity and prognosis in patients with chronic heart failure, the procedure for such a technique is complex and expensive. More simple exercise tests have been developed in this way. The distance walked in the six-minute walk test (6-MT) shows a moderate correlation with peak oxygen uptake [1], and some authors have suggested that a low performance in the 6-MT may predict ulterior cardiac events in these patients [1], [2], [3].
A shuttle walk test (SWT) has been developed to assess functional limitation in patients with obstructive chronic bronchitis [4]. It is a symptom-limited test, with a progressive structure. We [5] and others [6] have applied it to patients with chronic heart failure, finding that it is a feasible, simple and safe test. Moreover, we found that the distance walked in the SWT was an independent predictor of peak oxygen uptake in these patients, but distance in the 6-MT was not [5], [7].
We investigated if this recently developed test offers potential benefits with respect to the 6-MT in the prediction of prognosis in patients with chronic heart failure.
Section snippets
Methods
Forty-six patients (nine women), with a mean age of 53.0 (S.D., 10.5) years, NYHA class II–IV heart failure symptoms, and systolic dysfunction (ejection fraction <0.40; mean, 0.23; S.D., 0.08) were prospectively studied in our Heart Failure Clinic. Nineteen patients (41%) were in NYHA functional class II, 21 patients (46%) in NYHA class III, and six (13%) were in class IV. Usual clinical, echocardiographic, radionuclide–angiographic and rest hemodynamic variables were obtained for each patient,
Results
Clinical data and results from Doppler echocardiography, radionuclide–angiography, cardiopulmonary exercise testing, walk tests (SWT and 6-MT) and haemodynamics are displayed in Table 1. There were no relevant complications related to performance of any walk test. Univariate relationships to peak oxygen uptake were 0.83 for SWT distance (P<0.001), and 0.69 for 6-MT distance (P<0.001). Of note, all patients who walked >450 m in the SWT had a peak oxygen consumption >14 ml/kg/min.
After a mean
Discussion
In our study, walking a distance under 450 m in the SWT was associated with a significantly higher probability of experiencing a major cardiac event within 12 months than walking a longer distance. We did not find adequate risk stratification at 12 months for distance walked in the 6-MT. This result is consistent with that reported by Cahalin et al. [1], who found that 6-MT distance predicted event-free survival at 6 months, but not at one year. Bittner et al. [2] found distance ambulated in
Acknowledgements
Supported by a grant from the Public Health Service of Andalucı́a, Spain (Consejerı́a de Salud de la Junta de Andalucı́a).
References (9)
- et al.
The six-minute walk test predicts peak oxygen consumption and survival in patients with advanced heart failure
Chest
(1996) - et al.
Does the 6-minute walk test predict the prognosis in patients with NYHA class II or III chronic heart failure?
Am Heart J
(1998) - et al.
Shuttle walk test to assess chronic heart failure [letter]
Lancet
(1998) - et al.
A shuttle walk test for assessment of functional capacity in chronic heart failure
Am Heart J
(1999)
Cited by (62)
Incremental shuttle walk test distance and autonomic dysfunction predict survival in pulmonary arterial hypertension
2017, Journal of Heart and Lung TransplantationPredictors of shuttle walking test performance in patients with cardiovascular disease
2013, Physiotherapy (United Kingdom)Changes in cardiorespiratory fitness in cardiac rehabilitation patients: A meta-analysis
2013, International Journal of CardiologyCitation Excerpt :The inclusion of only incremental load-bearing exercise testing was made in an attempt to standardise the measurement of fitness. Lower values are often obtained from cycle ergometry and while field tests can estimate MET or V⋅o2peak values, the prediction equations used often have large standard errors of estimation [24]. These two criteria were designed to restrict the analysis to the most commonly-provided model of cardiac rehabilitation, similar to the criteria used in meta-analysis demonstrating the efficacy of CR in reducing mortality, morbidity and reducing risk factors [4, 7].
Walking tests during the exercise training: Specific use for the cardiac rehabilitation
2013, Annals of Physical and Rehabilitation MedicineCitation Excerpt :Ce test s’est avéré reproductible chez l’insuffisant cardiaque stable [80] ou en attente de greffe [73]. La distance de marche atteinte est corrélée au cours de l’ICC au pic de VO2 [80], mais elle ne permet pas de déterminer ce pic de façon satisfaisante chez des patients en post-infarctus du myocarde [115]. Il a une valeur prédictive de la morbidité cardiovasculaire à 1 an, la valeur seuil de 450 mètres apparaissant discriminante [80].
Development of the i-BODE: Validation of the incremental shuttle walking test within the BODE index
2012, Respiratory Medicine
- ☆
Presented in part at the 71st Scientific Sessions of the American Heart Association, Dallas, TX, USA, November 8–11, 1998.