Medical students' evolving perspectives on their personal health care: Clinical and educational implications of a longitudinal study

https://doi.org/10.1053/comp.2000.0410303Get rights and content

Abstract

The mental and physical health care issues of medical students are increasingly recognized as both prevalent and complex. Emotional distress, symptoms of mental illness, and maladaptive substance use are widespread and may often be driven by training-related stressors. The data suggest that nearly all medical students identify physical health concerns as well. The care of medical students as patients is complex because of problems associated with the stigma of various illnesses and the dual role of trainee and patient in medical school. A written confidential survey assessed students longitudinally near the end of their first and third years of training regarding their perceived health care needs, health concerns, attitudes toward care, access to services, and care-seeking practices (161 items). A subset of students (n = 33) were reassessed 1 month after the second survey to measure reliability. McNemar's chi-square (χ2) tests, repeated-measures multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA), and κ and Pearson correlations were used to evaluate outcomes. Almost all students reported health care needs during both training phases, and their mental and physical health concerns were stable over time. However, the preference for obtaining health care at a site other than their training institution and concerns about confidentiality increased, although students were marginally more likely to obtain care at their medical school during clinical versus preclinical training. The students' tendency to seek informal care from colleagues remained consistent, as did their high level of concern about professional jeopardy relating to personal health issues. Their tendency to accept the dual patient-student role depended on the particular health care issue; they expressed a strong tendency to protect other students' confidentiality, even in cases of potential significant impairment. Responses were reliable across a 1-month retest interval. We conclude that medical students' perspectives on their mental and physical health care across the transition from preclinical to clinical training reveal the importance of pursuing, not neglecting, a number of clinical and educational initiatives. Through their specialized expertise, psychiatrists may help to ensure sound mental and physical health care for the more than 69,000 medical students in training in this country.

References (0)

Cited by (44)

  • Sources of stress for pharmacy students in a nationwide sample

    2014, Currents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning
    Citation Excerpt :

    Health concerns were not a primary stressor, unlike what has been found previously for pharmacy students.19 Similar to medical students,34 pharmacy students may underreport or refuse treatment for health concerns because illness is stigmatized, or it is ignored in order to prevent academic consequences (e.g., missing rotations or exams).35 Another possibility is that this item may have been ambiguous, resulting in fewer participants selecting it.

  • Medical students as patients: Implications of their dual role as explored in a vignette-based survey study of 1027 medical students at nine medical schools

    2011, Comprehensive Psychiatry
    Citation Excerpt :

    An emerging literature suggests that medical students, like their physician colleagues, encounter significant obstacles when seeking personal health care [1-15]. Medical student–patients may have little time, few financial resources, limited access to venues for confidential care, and no or insufficient health insurance [6-9]. These barriers to appropriate care are worrisome in light of the significant mental and physical health issues experienced by physicians-in-training, such as increased rates of stress, anxiety, depression, suicide, alcohol use, and substance abuse, as well as heightened risk for developing hypertension and coronary artery disease and for exposure to infectious agents [3,16,17].

View all citing articles on Scopus

Supported in part by a seed grant from the Clinical Psychiatry/Psychology Research Foundation.

View full text