Making a diagnosis
BMJ 2003; 327 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.327.7413.494 (Published 28 August 2003) Cite this as: BMJ 2003;327:494
- Alison Taylor
Introduction
Couples present at a surgery or clinic because they have not conceived as quickly as they had expected. Some are concerned there may be serious problem that will stop them having a family. Subfertility investigations determine whether a problem exists and enable a rational discussion about options for treatment. The treatment may include waiting for a spontaneous conception. Some of the distress associated with subfertility may be reduced by a prompt and systematic protocol of investigations that allows couples to move quickly to the most appropriate treatment.
Couple consulting doctor
Investigations: who and when
Subfertility is defined as failure to conceive after one year of unprotected regular sexual intercourse. Although usually it would be reasonable to start investigations after this time, earlier investigations and referral may be justified where there are important factors in either partner's history.,
Factors that may warrant early referral or investigation*
A woman's age is one of the main factors affecting her chance of conception. The chances of most treatments being successful are reduced substantially after a woman reaches 35 years and become negligible by her mid-40s. Hence, if couples are to gain the maximum benefit from the most appropriate treatment, investigations should be started promptly (after six months of trying if the woman is over 35) and completed according to a locally agreed protocol between general practitioners and hospital providers. Couples can then be counselled about the implications of test results, and a management plan agreed that takes into account the test results and the couple's beliefs and wishes.
At initial presentation both partners should have a history taken and be examined. Regular intercourse two to three times a week should be advised, but basal body temperature charts are not helpful and should be avoided.
The female partner of couples presenting with subfertility should have their rubella status checked so that if immunisation is required it will not delay any treatment
A rational approach to investigation
Initial investigations should be completed within three to four months and should establish the following points.
Does the woman ovulate?
If not, then why not?
Is the semen quality normal?
Is there tubal damage or uterine abnormality? Both partners must be investigated because an appropriate plan of management cannot be formulated without considering both male and female factors that may occur concurrently. Initial investigations can be started in the community, with the assessment of tubal patency taking place in hospital
Initial investigations that can be done in primary care
Starting investigations in primary care
Does the woman ovulate and if not why not?
The UK Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists' guidelines include checking a mid-luteal phase progesterone to confirm ovulation in a regular cycle. Time the sample at the correct phase of the cycle (seven days before expected menses). Where cycles are irregular or the woman has oligomenorrhoea (a cycle length of > 35 days) or polymenorrhoea (< 25 days), ovulation is unlikely and so a progesterone test is of little value. Thyroid stimulating hormone, testosterone, and prolactin concentrations need be checked only if cycles are irregular or absent, suggesting anovulation, galactorrhoea, or symptoms of thyroid disorder. Transvaginal ultrasonography is a simple investigation that will detect polycystic ovaries and uterine fibroids. Luteinising hormone, FSH, and estradiol should be checked early in the cycle (days 2 to 6).
HyCoSy showing patency and flow through one cornu of the uterus
Is semen quality normal?
The male partner should have a semen analysis and if some parameters are abnormal, then a second test should be done six weeks later. Ideally the samples should be analysed in the laboratory used by the fertility clinic to which the couple will be referred. More detailed sperm function tests are not needed as a routine part of the initial investigations. The postcoital test is unreliable and is no longer recommended as a routine investigation.
Completing investigations in secondary care
Investigations started in primary care should be completed in a dedicated reproductive medicine or fertility clinic.
Investigations in secondary care
Is there tubal damage or uterine abnormality?
Assessment of a woman's tubal status and uterine cavity can be performed by
Hysterosalpingography (HSG)
Hysterosalpingo-contrast sonography (HyCoSy)
Laparoscopy and dye test with hysteroscopy.
Tests for tubal patency should take place in the first 10 days of a cycle to avoid the possibility, however unlikely, of disrupting an early spontaneous pregnancy. Unless cervical screening for chlamydia has been performed, prophylactic antibiotics such as doxycycline and metronidazole should be given to minimise the risk of infection developing after the procedure.
HSG and HyCoSy
Hysterosalpingogram showing a normal pelvis
HSG and HyCoSy are “dynamic” outpatient investigations done by inserting a catheter into the cervical canal, after which contrast is injected into the uterine cavity. HSG uses real time x ray imaging to follow the flow of contrast into the tubes and spill into the peritoneal cavity, whereas HyCoSy uses ultrasonography. Both give information about the shape of the uterine cavity. HyCoSy gives extra information because an ultrasound scan of the pelvis is performed at the same time, allowing the detection of fibroids or polycystic ovaries.
Laparoscopy and dye test
A laparoscopy and dye test needs general anaesthesia and carries the hazards of laparoscopy. However, it gives information about the degree of any tubal damage present and enables endometriosis to be detected. Additionally, laparoscopic treatment such as diathermy or laser ablation of endometriosis or salpingolysis or salpingostomy may be done at the same time. HyCoSy and HSG can be used as an initial screen, reserving laparoscopy for patients with a history or symptoms indicating a risk of tubal damage or endometriosis, and for those who have an abnormal HSG. If investigation of the male partner shows substantially impaired semen quality, such that assisted conception treatment (for example, intracytoplasmic sperm injection) is likely, tubal assessment may not be needed. However, information about the uterine cavity may be helpful if ultrasonography shows the presence of submucosal fibroids.
Laparoscopy showing a normal pelvis with passage of blue dye through the fimbrial end of the left tube
Further investigation of azoospermia in secondary care
Where the initial semen analysis reveals azoospermia a centrifuged sample should be examined for sperm in the pellet. Even if only a few sperm can be identified, intracytoplasmic sperm injection can be offered as effective treatment to circumvent the infertility.
Investigating azoospermia, by site of abnormality
If azoospermia is confirmed it is important to distinguish between obstructive and non-obstructive azoospermia.
In obstructive azoospermia, spermatogenesis is normal but there is a block in the epididymis or vas deferens. If congenital absence of vas deferens is suspected, both partners should undergo cystic fibrosis screening because many of these men will carry one of the cystic fibrosis mutations. In non-obstructive azoospermia, spermatogenesis is impaired. This impairment may be caused by testicular failure (so the man's karyotype should be checked and multiple testicular biopsy may show isolated foci of spermatogenesis) or due to a failure to stimulate spermatogenesis by the hypothalamic pituitary axis (hypogonadotrophic hypogonadism). Although rare, this condition should be detected as these patients respond to gonadotrophin treatment.
Interpreting results and discussing treatment options
Female partner
Where the progesterone concentration is low take the following steps.
Check the length of the cycle in which the sample was taken
Ensure that sample was taken in the mid-luteal phase–that is, seven days before expected period
Ensure that other endocrine tests are completed
An ultrasound scan is valuable to diagnose presence of polycystic ovaries if anovulation is confirmed or the luteinising hormone or testosterone concentrations, or both, are raised
Advise about weight gain or loss to achieve a body mass index (weight (kg)/(height (m)2)) of 20-30. This is the key to successful treatment.
Interpreting results of investigations of female partners
A single raised early follicular phase follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) concentration is a poor prognostic indicator for women trying to conceive. It implies a reduced ovarian reserve and the possibility of incipient premature ovarian failure. This is difficult to treat because the response to ovarian stimulation is likely to be poor. Refractory cases may need egg donation.
After an abnormal hysterosalpinogram or HyCoSy, further tubal assessment by laparoscopy will be needed. The main treatment options include:
Surgery (open or laparoscopic)
Transcervical tubal cannulation
In vitro fertilisation.
The choice of procedure will depend on factors such as the degree of tubal damage, the semen quality, and the patient's age. Intrauterine lesions such as submucous fibroids or adhesions need further evaluation by hysteroscopy, at which time they may be resected.
Male partner
Semen samples can vary greatly. If the semen volume is low, check whether collection of the ejaculate was complete. If the first part of the ejaculate, which contains most of the sperm, missed the pot, the results will not be representative.
Lubricants for masturbation–for example, soap or KY jelly may be spermicidal and their use should be avoided. If the male partner has difficulty producing a sample by masturbation then a non-spermicidal condom can be used.
Interpreting a semen analysis
Therapeutic drugs that may be associated with impaired spermatogenesis include chemotherapy, sulfasalazine, and cimetidine.
Abnormal semen qualities are an indication for early referral to a fertility clinic, preferably one offering a full range of assisted conception techniques.
Conclusion
Conclusion Couples who present with subfertility rarely have absolute infertility (that is, no chance of conception spontaneously). Factors that are contributing to the problem usually cause relative subfertility (that is, a reduced chance of conceiving spontaneously) to a greater or lesser degree, and there may be relevant factors in both partners.
Investigations should follow a systematic protocol designed to identify:
Tubal or uterine abnormalities
Anovulation
Impaired spermatogenesis.
Prompt investigation and appropriate referral allow a couple to receive advice and treatment to help them reach their goal of a pregnancy more quickly, and may alleviate some of the distress associated with subfertility. Doctors in primary care can have an invaluable role in starting this process and providing support during further investigation and treatment.
Further reading
Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists evidence based clinical guidelines. Initial investigation and management of the subfertile couple. London: RCOG Press, 1998
Templeton A, Ashok P, Bhattacharya S,Gazvani R, Hamilton M, MacMillan S, et al. Evidence based fertility treatment London: RCOG Press, London, 2000
Balen A, Jacobs H. Infertility in practice. 2nd ed. London: Churchill Livingstone, 2003
Templeton A, Ashok P, Bhattacharya S, Gazuani R, Hamilton M, MacMillan S, et al. Management of infertility for the MRCOG and beyond. London: RCOG Press, 2000
The ABC of subfertility is edited by Peter Braude, professor and head of department of women's health, Guy's, King's, and St Thomas's School of Medicine, London, and Alison Taylor, consultant in reproductive medicine and director of the Guy's and St Thomas's assisted conception unit.. The series will be published as a bookin the winter.
Footnotes
-
Competing interests None declared